The Ugly IV Skew Secret: Why ‘Cheap’ Puts Can Wipe Out Your Account Overnight

 If you think you’re getting a bargain by buying “cheap” OTM puts whenever IV skew looks steep—you’re playing a deadly game of Russian roulette with your portfolio.

Market makers know exactly what they’re doing when they set skew—and it’s not to gift you a discount. It’s to manage their own risk. And if you don’t understand why puts look cheap, you could be the next trader left holding the bag.

---

🤔 What Is IV Skew, Really?

Most traders learn that:

• Implied Volatility (IV) rises with demand for protection.

• Skew is the pattern of IV across strikes (puts vs. calls).

When puts trade at higher IV than calls, that’s put skew or a “volatility smile”. In theory, “cheap” puts are just cheaper insurance. In reality, they’re a warning sign.

---

🚨 The Market Maker’s Playbook

1. Balancing the Books
   Market makers sell options to collect premium. To hedge, they buy the underlying or other options. They set skew to ensure they’re compensated for tail risk—the tiny chance of a massive move.

2. Risk Transfer
   A steep put skew means they’re charging you extra to protect against crashes. “Cheap” puts further OTM? They’re usually less liquid and reflect repositioning risk, not safety.

3. Dynamic Hedging Costs
   As the underlying moves, market makers delta-hedge dynamically. In a crash, they’ll buy stock as the price falls, pushing it down faster—and re-pricing IV even higher.

Bottom line: Those “discount” puts aren’t a gift—they’re priced for disaster you can’t see.

---

💣 Real-Life Horror Story

Last October, during the flash sell-off, a friend bought deep OTM puts on a major tech ETF because the skew looked “too good.” He doubled down on the idea that puts farther from the money must be cheapskate bargains.

When that 5% drop turned into a 15% freefall, his options went from “cheap” to worthless in minutes. The skew inverted so violently that even his far OTM puts had IVs that exploded—yet they were untradeable due to thin liquidity.

He lost 40% of his position—not because he was wrong directionally, but because he underestimated the hidden costs baked into skew.

---

🔍 Why “Cheap” Puts Are Death Traps

1. Sparse Liquidity
   Far-OTM strikes rarely trade. You’ll face huge bid-ask spreads when you need out.

2. Exploding Hedging Costs
   In a crash, dynamic hedgers force IV even higher, making your puts skyrocket in theoretical price—but impossible to sell.

3. Vol Surface Shocks
   A skew shift during panic doesn’t just lift puts—it warps the entire vol surface. Your model’s assumptions break down.

---

🛠️ How to Trade Skew Safely

1. Use Spreads, Not Naked Puts
   Put credit spreads limit your max loss and guarantee you can exit. You capture skew without unbounded risk.

2. Watch Risk Reversals
   A 1×1 call-put reversal (sell a put, buy a call) shows you the true cost of skew. If the reversal is wide, it’s a red flag.

3. Focus on Liquid Strikes
   Stick to strikes near the money where bid-ask spreads are tight and you can actually trade.

4. Model Tail Scenarios
   Run a vol surface shock in your pricing model: shock IV by +50% across all strikes. See how it impacts your P&L—not just the current IV.

---

💡 Down-to-Earth Takeaway

IV skew isn’t a quirky graph on your options chain—it’s a map of hidden risks that market makers don’t want retail traders to fully parse. Those “cheap” puts? They’re priced for all the nasty things that can happen in a panic—things you often only learn the hard way.

Stop chasing bargains in the dark. Understand the skew dynamics, trade smart spreads, and always account for the real cost of insurance.